Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Difference Without Disturbance: Visibility, Dependency and Belonging in a Temporary Organisation

Parallel Papers Session
Day and time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27T
Presenter: Manshreya Grover and Hala Malak
Moderator: to be announced

M_Grover-portrait.jpg
hala_malak_photo-0001.jpeg

Manshreya Grover

Hala Malak

Manshreya Grover is an organisational researcher and consultant working in systems psychodynamics. Her research examines authority, group relations, institutional mourning, and how organisations negotiate dependency, difference and uncertainty. She is completing an MA in Systems and Psychodynamic Approaches at the Tavistock and Portman. Her work has appeared in the International Forum of Psychoanalysis and Group & Organization Management, with forthcoming work with Vernon Press. She is the recipient of the 2025 Maurice Burke Essay Prize.

Hala Malak is a transdisciplinary researcher, designer, and educator whose work explores organizational systems, institutional change, and the ways knowledge is produced, transmitted, and held through relational and embodied forms of practice. She is an Assistant Professor of Strategic Design and Management at Parsons School of Design, The New School, where she has held academic leadership roles and led organizational and program transformation. Her current research considers questions of authority, difference, belonging, and knowledge transmission, with particular interest in what becomes visible or remains unspoken. She is currently completing her MA in systems psychodynamics at the Tavistock and Portman Fund and her PhD in Transdisciplinary Research and Practice at RMIT.

What kinds of difference can a group recognise without disturbance, and what happens when acknowledging difference begins to locate danger within the group?

This paper draws on our experience as members of a four-day Group Relations Conference that opened with Freud’s claim that civilization replaces individual power with communal power. We became interested not only in when difference became consequential, but in when it could be named at all. Some differences, including geography and professional role, were easier to acknowledge, though often only briefly. Others seemed more dangerous because recognition risked locating aggression, exclusion, violence or morally troubling qualities in particular members or positions. Two experiences drew our attention: Some members, including ourselves, moved easily between groups and relationships. This mobility was welcomed as adaptability and self-sufficiency, but may also have made these members difficult to place. Yet when a mobile member needed something from others, the group’s response seemed to change. Elsewhere, when required to authorize an interim management from among itself, the membership selected a configuration described as “bland.”

Drawing on Klein’s account of paranoid-schizoid functioning, Bion’s work on group dependency, and Menzies Lyth’s concept of social defence, we hypothesise that the temporary organisation managed anxieties generated by difference partly by regulating recognition and attribution. The difficulty may have lain less in difference itself than in what acknowledging it required the group to locate: someone wanting authority, someone being preferred or excluded, someone needing another, or a member or position carrying aggression or danger. The task could authorise differentiation where desire could not: management was needed, but wanting authority, needing others or preferring particular members was harder to own. We distinguish visible difference from consequential difference, treating difference not as a trait members possess but as something negotiated through recognition, attribution dependency and authority. Visible difference can be acknowledged without substantially disturbing the group’s image of itself. Consequential difference introduces asymmetry, desire and attribution. If no one becomes too particular, preferred, needy or authoritative, then envy, competition and aggression can remain less located. The “bland” selection may therefore be read as a defensive compromise: task-required differentiation was achieved while dangerous particularity was muted. Both of us occupied mobile positions and crossed group boundaries easily. Rather than treating this as evidence of our independence, we ask whether mobility allowed us to remain relatively unlocated within the group’s conflicts, and what changed when need made positions more visible. We also consider moments when conflictual experience was softened into formulations such as “not being heard,” or displaced into discussion of “isms,” allowing difference to be spoken while reducing the need to locate agency, aggression or exclusion in the here-and-now.

Our session aims to develop and test consequential difference as a systems-psychodynamic hypothesis. It is intended for organisational consultants, researchers, leaders and group-relations practitioners. Through a brief conceptual presentation, anonymised case material, experiential reflection, and discussion, participants will examine how organizations may recognize difference while defending against the dependency, competition, aggression, and claims to authority that make difference consequential, We ask: what does it cost to remain different and still belong?