Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

A view from the trenches- surviving while surrendering omnipotence within the Irish Public Health System

Parallel Papers Session
Day and time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27S
Presenter: Grainne Flynn, Belinda Moller and Chris Scanlon
Moderator: to be announced

grainne_Flynn1.jpg
Belinda_Moller_photo_March_26.jpeg

Grainne Flynn

Belinda Moller

cid_8494C09C-FD05-489A-ABE6-0734860DA9A8.jpeg

Chris Scanlon

Grainne Flynn is a Consultant Adult Psychiatrist working in public mental health services for the past 26 years in the NHS and Ireland. She completed training in group analytic psychotherapy and qualified as a group analyst in 2025. She is a full member of the Irish Group Analytic Society. 

Belinda Moller has been practicing, consulting and teaching psychoanalytically and psychodynamically since 2006. Trained as a group analyst, she integrates the group analytic lens into Balint group work, organisation & role consultation, training and process groups, reflective practice group work and group analytic psychotherapy. Belinda has a PhD in Strategy from Trinity College Dublin (2008). She is a Group Analyst and a member of The Irish Group Analytic Society (IGAS). She is an accredited leader with The Balint Society, UK, and a member of The Organisation for Promoting Understanding of Society (OPUS), ISPSO, and The Association of Psychosocial Studies. Formerly a Co-chair of The ISPSO Annual Meeting in Dublin in 2018, Belinda is currently Chair of The Irish Council for Psychotherapy during a time of State regulation of the profession.

Dr Christopher Scanlon, (DPhil) Consultant Adult & Forensic Psychotherapist, Psychosocial Researcher/Consultant, Training Group Analyst (Institute of Group Analysis (London) and Irish group Analytic Society (Dublin)) and senior professional associate Tavistock Institute of Human Relations (TIHR)

Society demands that health care staff are creative, thoughtful and person centred. That they know the answer to, and can eliminate, all suffering. On their part, health care staff are motivated to work within the sector due to their unconscious dependency needs ( Dartington,2010) . They may identify with the projected omnipotence from society as a means of protecting and distancing themselves from the realities of the work ( Kraemer, 2015).  We will argue that societies urge for certainty is a primitive defence, that on the one hand, protects society against anxiety but on the other, produces an infantilised culture of impossible demands resulting in demoralised health care staff, that can lead to the neglect of patients or clients. We will theorise how the historical origins of universal health services after the second world war, such as the British NHS, set unrealistic expectations, resulting in omnipotent cycles of idealisation and denigration ( Gibbons, 2025).

Within this culture and fragmented health service (Adlam 2019), staff are treated like assembly line workers tasked to provide quick fixes and easy solutions while faced with an ever growing workload and profoundly complex cases. Staff are squeezed between the higher management and organisational anxieties about risk and regulation and the anxieties of patients and families. The failure to meet these impossible and often competing demands, creates fear of retribution or destruction in staff.   

Influenced by David Armstrong’s concept of the organisation-in-the-mind, ( Armstrong, 1991, 2005, 2015, 2019, 2023) this case presentation will offer specific examples from Ireland’s public health system concerning work with staff groups. One of us, a group analyst, will discuss leading a staff support group from “outside” the organisation. The other will describe leading a health team “within” the organisation as both a psychiatrist and group analyst, dealing with the omnipotent fantasies of “mastering” outcomes. We will illustrate material with case vignettes.

This paper is the result of two years of developmental collaborative work by the authors to articulate and frame the hidden emotional and psychological dimensions between the individual, the group’s psyche and the larger institutional system specific to the Irish health system.  

The aim is to provide a theoretical and practice frame, whilst the authors attempt to locate the group analytic stance within this system, positing that such a stance  and its capacity to contain, is vital for thinking, linking and for generating meaning in difficult and extraordinary situations ( Foulkes1990). .

We invite group discussion around the following questions;

How can leaders support staff to surrender omnipotent defences and build potency, individually and collectively in teams?

Is the omnipotent defence more relevant in health care organisations due to individual unconscious motivations for care giving with its denial of dependency?

How are these individual omnipotent defences strengthened collectively into social defences when faced with societal expectations?

How does a predominantly female profession impact on these defences?

As group analysts we value interdependence and wonder how, or if, this can be fostered when there is unequal power and pay within health teams?