Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Curiosity, Omniscience and Bion's K at the Threshold of Inquiry

Parallel Papers Session
Day and time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27O
Presenter: Nicola Brazil
Moderator: to be anounced

Professional_Photo.jpeg

Nicola Brazil

Updated biography pending

A senior leader describes a recurring moment in peer group meetings:

I might highlight a ‘Why did we do that', and there's an uncomfortable silence, and then somebody will say: 'Well hang on, we're a pretty good team overall... I'm not sure we need to do too much navel gazing; we operate pretty well'...so we kind of acknowledge it... but we don't prod it if we think it's too scary.

Curiosity represents an organisational conundrum - invoked as a virtue, whilst systemic conditions simultaneously constrain it. Mainstream literature treats curiosity as an individual trait which can be measured and improved, yet this framing ignores what becomes of curiosity when it meets the organisation.

The emotional tensions described by Freud and Klein cast curiosity as a vital impulse towards knowing. Bion shifts the focus from instinctual drive to K; one of three relational links (with L and H), through which experience becomes thinkable by staying in contact with what is encountered rather than evading it. -K is curiosity’s antithesis; an impulse not to know. Containment renders inquiry tolerable; its absence distorts curiosity into defensive forms.

A reading of K and -K emerged from an abductive systems psychodynamic doctoral study of curiosity in a 30,000+ knowledge-intensive company in a highly-regulated sector, which names curiosity as a leadership value. A threshold space surfaced: the relational, often ?eeting moment when internal experience met the system, where dynamics such as identity, role expectations and collective defences operated at once. It is where movements toward and away from K, became observable. The study suggests that the fate of curiosity at these moments does not re?ect organisational conditions; it discloses them.

Curiosity was generative in the presence of sufficient containment and became performative – used as a shield and weapon - without. This was compounded by a systemic need for control through expertise - omnipotence taking the form of omniscience. The claim to know everything is what incompleteness became when it could not be thought. Omniscience and incompleteness were therefore not opposites but a single movement.

Threshold space names where K and -K oscillation becomes potentially intervenable, extending Bion’s framework to organisational application. The organisation’s epistemic life becomes most visible in those seconds in which a question was quickly closed, a silence broken or identity preserved. It reveals the potential cost of curiosity - the ongoing negotiation with what the system is willing to know and what must be defended against. This may help explain why initiatives to develop curiosity in organisations may reproduce the conditions that constrains it. Control reduces anxiety by managing what emerges; containment holds anxiety long enough for meaning to form.

This paper is aimed at ISPSO members and colleagues in organisational consulting, coaching and action research, and all those curious about what might help and hinder curiosity. Working methods: a short presentation offered as material rather than ?ndings, including the researcher’s own de?ected curiosity; individual re?ection on a threshold moment of the participant’s own; small- and large-group discussion in which the group’s own movements toward and away from inquiry may be studied as they

Participants will leave having examined where their own inquiry closed, and what was available to hold it, and what that might disclose about the systems they work in.