Online Conference 5-11 July 2021
February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria
Parallel Papers Session
Day and time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27N
Presenter: Nuala Dent
Moderator: to be announced
Nuala Dent
Dr Nuala Dent is an executive coach and leadership and culture consultant based in Melbourne, Australia. She has nearly two decades of experience working with
senior leaders and leadership teams across complex organisational settings. Her practice integrates systems psychodynamics, reflective inquiry and arts-based methods, with a particular
interest in the relational and organisational dynamics that shape leadership, culture and the experience of work.
Nuala holds a PhD in organisation dynamics and is an Associate Editor of "Organisational and Social Dynamics".
Freud’s observation that the ego is “not master in its own house” challenged the idea of a rational subject capable of fully knowing and governing itself. More than a century later, AI gives this problem of knowing and mastery a new context. AI can synthesise information, present knowledge, support decisions and increasingly act within organisational processes. The more convincingly it does so, the more it raises a question about the difference between knowledge and knowing.
Drawing on extended epistemology (Heron and Reason, 1997), intersubjective thinking (Benjamin, 1988) and systems psychodynamics (Gould, Stapley and Stein, 2001), this workshop proposes that knowledge can be represented and communicated in propositional form, while knowing cannot be reduced to possessing, processing or presenting information. Knowing is grounded in embodied and intersubjective experience. AI does not experience the world, yet can present what we recognise as knowledge. What happens when we encounter AI as though it knows?
Building on Armstrong’s (2005) concept of ‘organisation-in-the-mind’, the workshop introduces ‘organisation-in-the-model’ as a way of thinking about the representation of an organisation that AI might generate, shaped by patterns and assumptions embedded in the model and by the information available to it. Unlike organisation-in-the-mind, this representation is not grounded in the perceptions of an experiencing subject. Nor does it offer an objective view: neither organisation-in-the-mind nor organisation-in-the-model provides an unmediated account of organisational life; each is partial in fundamentally different ways.
The workshop aims to explore the human-AI working relation as a psychodynamic process and to examine what may happen when organisation-in-the-mind encounters organisation-in-the-model. Participants will be invited to consider what we might attribute or project onto AI; what may be revealed, amplified or obscured in the encounter; and what happens to knowing and judgement as humans and AI increasingly work together.
The workshop is intended for consultants, coaches, leaders, researchers, and others interested in the psychoanalytic and systems psychodynamic dimensions of working with AI. Following a short presentation of the conceptual framework, participants will work reflectively with their own experiences of encountering and working with AI, individually and in small groups, before bringing their observations and emerging hypotheses into discussion with the group-as-a-whole.
Participants will leave with a conceptual lens for examining human-AI relations in organisational life, and greater capacity to notice the assumptions, projections and attributions that may shape their own encounters with AI. Together, we will consider what these emerging relations might reveal about knowing, judgement, omnipotence, incompleteness and the enduring human wish to be master in our own house.