Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Containing the Unthinkable: When the Political Crosses the Boundaries of Mind, Relationship, and Organization

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27I
Presenter: Carleen Miller
Moderator: to be announced

cm_headshot.jpg

Carleen Miller

Carleen Miller, PhD, LP, LMFT
Dr. Miller is a psychotherapist, psychoanalyst, couple and family therapist, clinical supervisor and an organizational consultant. She works with individuals, couples, families and organizations.
Dr. Miller received her PhD in Clinical Social Work at the Institute for Clinical Social Work in Chicago, Illinois. She also holds a master’s degree in Couple and Family Therapy. She received postdoctoral training in psychoanalysis at the National Institute for the Psychotherapies. Additionally, she received a certificate in psychoanalytic psychotherapy from the Cincinnati Psychoanalytic Institute and a certificate in global mental health, trauma and recovery from the Harvard University Continuing Education Studies Program.
Dr. Miller is on the board of directors of the National Institute for the Psychotherapies in New York City. Additionally, she serves as the Director of the National Training Program in Contemporary Psychoanalysis at the National Institute for the Psychotherapies (NIP). She is a faculty member of NIP, ICP+P in Washington DC, and the Institute for Clinical Social Work in Chicago.
Dr. Miller serves as the Chief People Officer for a Global Humanitarian and Human Rights organization that works with Refugees, Immigrants and other marginalized communities. Her experience as an organizational leader provides her with a unique perspective. Additionally, she has served as the Executive Director of a Refugee Resettlement Organization and the Director of Social Services for a Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Human Trafficking program and shelter.
Dr. Miller works with a wide range of concerns including anxiety, depression, life transitions, relationship challenges, trauma, spiritual concerns, grief/loss, migration trauma, issues related to LGBTQI+ identity, work stress, climate change, women’s and men’s issues as well as other concerns.

This paper examines how sociopolitical crisis moves across interconnected psychological and institutional settings. Following the November 2024 election of Donald Trump to a second term and the subsequent disruption of U.S. humanitarian aid, political conflict entered three mutually influencing fields in my life: my work with patients, my leadership of a humanitarian organization, and my own psychoanalysis. Across these settings, omnipotence, control, and dissociation emerged as defenses against fear, helplessness, dependency, vulnerability, and uncertainty.

One patient, John, a fervent critic of “liberals,” believed they were destroying the country and diverting resources from Americans to immigrants and foreign countries. His vitriol intensified after the election. As a human rights advocate, organizational leader, and psychoanalyst, I was disturbed by his views. After the 2025 inauguration, executive orders halted aid initiatives, including the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program. Federal funds were frozen, life-saving contracts terminated, and refugees cleared for travel returned to camps. The funding loss destabilized my organization, threatened its mission, and ultimately required me to lay off 1,500 employees, many of them former refugees and immigrants.

My leadership colleagues and I had to project steadiness while absorbing shock, grief, anger, guilt, and responsibility for decisions we had not created. Under conditions of urgency, reflection narrowed and the pull toward omnipotent action, control, and dissociation intensified. We centralized decisions, overfunctioned, and compartmentalized emotion as though mastery or detachment could undo vulnerability. These defenses enabled immediate functioning but also concentrated responsibility, strained communication, and distanced leaders from one another and from staff members’ emotional reality.

The organizational crisis entered both my treatment with John and my own analysis. I carried into the consulting room fear, despair, and responsibility for employees facing sudden loss. In my analysis, I began to recognize how competence, decisiveness, control, and detachment could defend against rage, guilt, dependency, helplessness, and uncertainty. The conflict with John increasingly mirrored the dynamics unfolding in the organization: the wish to master an intolerable reality or dissociate from its emotional force rather than experience the fear beneath it.

During seven years of intensive treatment, John and I had navigated complex transference and countertransference. Yet during this period, the pressures that narrowed reflection in the organization also narrowed my analytic freedom. We entered an enactment organized around certainty, control, and dissociative withdrawal. I avoided eye contact, disengaged emotionally, and lost access to loving feelings toward him. His aggression and insistence on mastery pulled me toward defensiveness, countercontrol, and detachment. Institutional injury made it difficult to experience him solely as my patient rather than, in part, as a representative of forces threatening the organization and those we served. Beneath our struggle for control and retreat into dissociation lay fear, vulnerability, and helplessness that neither of us could readily tolerate.

The paper explores how these three settings illuminate one another: work with John exposed the personal force of political polarization; organizational leadership revealed how collective trauma can generate fantasies of mastery, rigid control, and dissociative distancing; and my own analysis provided a space in which underlying fear, dependency, uncertainty, vulnerability, and helplessness became more thinkable. I ask whether recognizing omnipotence, control, and dissociation as defenses against intolerable affect can restore reflective capacity, emotional presence, shared responsibility, and the possibility of repair.