Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

The Smell Test: recovering a 19th Century Freudian theory to combat a 21st Century omnipotence epidemic

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced

Paper code: PP27G
Presenter: Steven Reisner
Moderator: to be announced

Reisner_photo_217.jpeg

Steven Reisner

Steven Reisner, PhD is a psychoanalyst, Freud scholar, podcaster, essayist and political activist. He is a founding member of the Coalition for an Ethical Psychology, Advisor on Psychology and Ethics for Physicians for Human Rights and is on the faculty of the Stephen Mitchell Relational Study Center.

Dr. Reisner has been a consultant on issues of trauma, torture, political violence, disaster, and resilience in the face of catastrophic events for the United Nations, the European Council, the International Criminal Court, the International Organization for Migrations and other international humanitarian and mental health organizations and has provided training for clinicians and organizations after disasters and political violence in Haiti, Kosovo, Kurdistan, and Ethiopia.

Dr. Reisner is the recipient of Society for Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Psychology's (Division 39) Leadership Award, the New York State Psychological Association's Beacon Award, and the National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis' Vision Award. He has been published widely, mostr recently on psychoanalysis and politics for Slate.com, and also in Psychoanalytic Dialogues, JAPA, Studies in Gender and Sexuality and in The New York Times.

Along with a small, dedicated group of psychologist-activists, Dr. Reisner fought to prohibit psychologists from continuing in their central role in abusive CIA and military interrogation and detention processes. As a result of these efforts, APA policy on psychologists' involvement in interrogations was changed, and psychologists were removed from detention operations at Guantanamo Bay.

His podcast, Madness: Where Psychology and Fascism Collide, has had over 80,000 downloads and has reached listeners in 112 countries. In a former career, Dr. Reisner was an Obie award winning theater director, and more recently, co-producer on Michael Moore's documentary film, Fahrenheit 11/9.

I spend half the year in a little village in southwest France, where, especially in summer and autumn, the area is redolent of the tension of smells – odors that sit between the chemistries of pleasure and decay and which, if we allow ourselves, remind us of the exquisite nature of our mortality.

It could be said that, for the French, the sublime itself is a specialty of the nose; it’s the nose that distinguishes a great wine from a good wine, a mushroom from a truffle. The French believe that the nose is the key to civilization. Think Charles de Gualle, Gerard Depardieu, Cyrano de Bergerac.

But what the French divine culturally, Freud examined psychoanalytically. After his youthful stint with Charcot in Paris, Freud returned to Vienna veritably exploding with theories about human psychology. Two of his abandoned theories of that period, the ‘Seduction Hypothesis,’ and the ‘Project for a Scientific Psychology,’ are today part of the folklore of psychoanalysis. But a third theory, perhaps the most French-influenced, about the role of the nose in human sexuality and morality, is almost unknown. Freud called it his “dreckology” (Masson, 1985). 

The theory contends that when humans stood upright, the physical and emotional distance which separated the nose from anus and genitals gave rise to a profound and unique transformation: humans, alone among the animals, developed a sense of disgust and revulsion toward decay, creating an internal split between the moral and the instinctual. Shame, repression, ethics, sexuality and sublime pleasure are all implicated in the ambivalent dance with our own bestial smells. (Freud 1961/1930)

But, especially since COVID, this sense of smell has been increasingly lost, first as a physical symptom, but since then as a symptom of a quite different epidemic, an epidemic of virtual human communication, which itself presaged a more radical viral turn - to AI interfaces.

In this presentation, I will argue that the current culture of omnipotent thinking, in politics, organizations and everyday social interactions, is abetted by the loss of the ethical and animal guidance offered to humans by their sense of smell. AI characters offer “human” communication, and even psychotherapy, but lacking precisely those aspects of human interaction that Freud would regard as quintessentially human, offering a two-dimensional world increasingly taken for the three-dimensional world. 

I will argue (with Freud) that without a sense of smell we lose the constant, unconscious reminder of the inevitability of death. Hence, omnipotence and the demand for immortality become not just aspirations, but a dominant personality style, not only in the autistic and narcissistic thinking of techno-oligarchs and autocratic leaders, but in the wider population that is being trained to replace smelly human interactions with pristine screen- and AI-mediated ones. 

I will illustrate these notions using the radical changes in the communication style, governance processes and values prioritized on the listserv of an American psychoanalytic organization, which has shifted to almost exclusively virtual interactions where, before, its governance and exchanges took place at in-person meetings and conferences.