Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

From Basic Assumptions to Reversals: Re-thinking Group Work Through Reversal and Systems Psychodynamic Theory

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27E
Presenter: Manon de Jongh, Larry Hirschhorn and Anna Reiche
Moderator: to be announced

ManonDeJongh_2802_11zon-lav_størrelse.jpg
Larry-portrait.png

Manon de Jongh

 Larry Hirschhorn

Anna-Reich-Small.jpg

Anna Reiche

Manon de Jongh works at the intersection of leadership, organizational and personal development, multiparty and interorganizational collaboration, co-creation, democratic development, and whole systems change. As Assistant Professor and Head of the Center for Organizational Psychology at Roskilde University, she combines research, teaching, and consultancy to support leaders, organizations, and cross-sector partnerships in navigating complexity. Her work is informed by organizational psychology and systems psychodynamic theory, with a particular interest in group dynamics. She has extensive experience with leadership development, public sector innovation, citizens' assemblies, and collaborative governance. Across research and practice, her ambition is to contribute to more reflective, democratic, and sustainable ways of organizing and leading change across organizational and societal boundaries.

Larry Hirschhorn is a principal and founder of CFAR, a management consulting firm based in Philadelphia. He is also a founding member and former president of the International Society for the Psychoanalytic Study of Organizations. He has taught at The Wharton School, the University of Pennsylvania, and Fielding University. He has authored five books, including The Workplace Within, Reworking Authority, and Managing in the New Team Environment. He has received awards for his publications from the American Psychological Association, The Consulting Psychology Journal, and the American Management Association. He serves as director of CFAR’s Dynamics of Consulting Program. He is married to Marla Isaacs and lives in Philadelphia. He has a son and five grandchildren.

Anna Reiche is a psychologist, systems psychodynamic consultant, and EMCC-accredited team coach working with groups, leadership teams, founders, and organizational partnerships. She has worked as a coach \ consultant in more than 300 group and team sessions and serves as a consultant at Group Relations Conferences. Her practice focuses on unconscious group dynamics, authority and role, leadership, conflict, anxiety, psychological safety, and the capacity of teams to remain engaged with their task under pressure.

Anna combines clinical and psychoanalytic training with 12 years of senior-level business experience in marketing, organizational development, and entrepreneurship. She is a PhD candidate in organizational behaviour, researching relational conflict and innovation, a member of ISPSO, and an intervisor on the Master’s programme in Psychoanalysis and Psychoanalytic Business Consulting at HSE University. Her work integrates systems thinking, Bionian group theory, and close attention to the emotional life of organizations.

This paper explores whether Reversal Theory (Apter, 1981), recently adapted to group psychodynamics by Hirschhorn (2026), can extend systems psychodynamic thinking about how groups work. Bion (1952) provides an account of how groups retreat from work through Basic Assumptions, but a less differentiated account of the forms working itself takes. Hirschhorn proposes four workgroup modalities: challenge–consensus, purposeful–playful, performing–joining, and self-attunement–other-attunement. Effective groups “reverse” between complementary modes as circumstances require.

This perspective suggests a different understanding of the anxiety, frustration, and boredom that arise in groups. Rather than signaling regression, these experiences may indicate that a group has remained too long in one mode and needs to reverse. A group emphasizing consensus may need challenge; one preoccupied with performance may need joining. When groups lose this capacity, working modes may become deformed: challenging can become destroying, while joining can become suffocating. Reversal Theory thus offers experience-near terms for describing primitive functioning alongside generalized psychodynamic concepts such as paranoid-schizoid functioning (Klein, 1946). The question is whether this framework makes successful work and its deformation more observable while retaining attention to unconscious processes.

The paper reports on a qualitative pilot study within an advanced educational program in leadership and organizational psychology. Beginning in August 2026, two groups of nine participants are followed across eight sessions studying here-and-now processes. They are facilitated by consultants working within the classical systems psychodynamic tradition. This allows Reversal Theory to be examined within an established group-relations practice rather than groups organized around the theory.

The inquiry is iterative. Consultants conduct the groups in their customary way and subsequently share observations, asking whether episodes can be understood through the four modalities, movements between modes, and possible deformations. After three sessions, consultants discuss their observations with two Reversal Theory experts. By February 2027, observations from eight sessions in each group will inform a preliminary thematic analysis. This examines recurring patterns and critical episodes alongside psychodynamic phenomena including authority, dependency, fight-flight, projection, and containment. Selected observations will then be explored through structured coding to assess whether it adds useful differentiation.

The research process itself provides additional data. Introducing Reversal Theory has elicited both interest and resistance among faculty and consultants, including reluctance to use coding sheets. These responses show what happens when a new conceptual language enters an established tradition.

The study asks whether Reversal Theory helps consultants recognize dimensions of productive and primitive group functioning less differentiated through the lens of Basic Assumptions, and whether consultants can facilitate productive reversals as well as interpret regression. If so, it may provide an experience-near bridge between systems psychodynamic depth and the practical demands of leadership and group consultation. This also connects directly to the AM27 theme: neither leaders, groups, nor consultants are fully masters of a group’s state of mind. Organizational maturity lies not in permanent control, but in recognizing limits, using anxiety as information, and recovering movement when work requires it.

 

References

Apter, M. J. (1981). The possibility of a structural phenomenology: The case of reversal theory. Journal of Phenomenological Psychology, 12(2), 173–187.

Bion, W. R. (1952). Group dynamics: A re-view. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 33, 235–247.

Hirschhorn, L. (2026). Reversal theory and group psychodynamics (unpublished).

Klein, M. (1946). Notes on some schizoid mechanisms. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 27, 99–110.