Online Conference 5-11 July 2021
February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria
Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27C
Presenter: Simon Western
Moderator: to be anounced
Simon Western
Simon Western is founder CEO of the Eco-Leadership Institute, host of Edgy Ideas podcast, author of Leadership a critical text, Coaching and mentoring a critical text, Entanglements weaving our futures: past President of ISPSO previously Director of Coaching Lancaster University Management school, Director of Masters Tavistock Clinic: Consults to global companies on leadership and ecosystems. Leads Diploma in Coaching and Organisational Transformation.
This paper uses a dual lens, applying both eco-leadership and psychoanalytic theory and practice, to examine omnipotence and incompleteness as dynamics in a global vehicle manufacturer. Following a troubled launch in the company's most important product line, significant delays, recalls, and financial losses led to an invitation for our organisation to conduct action-research into the underlying causes and mitigate future risk.
A two-year internal review had offered technical and rational explanations for the failures. We were invited in because, in the client's words, the rational-technical approach was insufficient: the challenges they faced were beyond their understanding — despite their engineering and management expertise, they were not "masters in their own house."
Ecosystem structures and ecosystem cultures are entangled. Structurally, top-down hierarchy was no longer fit for purpose as the company faced growing interdependencies across software providers, functions in different geographic regions, global supply chains, and new commercial partners. The company could not master its own house for two key reasons: first, (omnipotence) a Messiah-Controller leadership approach bred grandiose fantasies of control, and a top-down culture silenced dissent and fostered toxic blame; second,(incompleteness) the house itself extended beyond its walls into an interdependent ecosystem the company neither owned nor controlled.
Omnipotence: "we make the impossible possible."
Incompleteness: "it takes an ecosystem to manufacture a vehicle."
The project has two phases: action-research, and implementation of recommendations. The first phase, 27 senior leader interviews and two cross-functional focus groups, identified a deeply embedded "hero-crisis" culture, captured in recurring refrains such as "we love a crisis" and "we will deliver no matter what," expressing an organisational grandiosity explained through Klein's concept of the manic defense, mobilised against anxieties and limitation, and partly through Lacan. The paper proposes that the "hero-crisis" pattern functioned not only as defence but as symptom and jouissance; a pleasure-in-displeasure that became repetition. Messiah and Controller Leadership (Western, 2019) became the ideal, “we love a hero” offering a méconnaissance, a misrecognition of unified mastery and whole, that concealed an organisation unable and unwilling to recognise its own splitting, vulnerability and interdependence. What was lacking was an ecosystems perspective: the company operated with the logic of a 20th-century industrial giant whose success was inevitable, while the reality was an existential crisis unleashed across the whole car industry. The production-line factory had produced a "production-line organisation-in-the-mind" (Armstrong), unable to think about connectivity and relationships beyond its control.
Phase two traces how our diagnosis was translated into structural and relational-cultural intervention. A structural response produced a Hub and Ecosystem Operating Model, embedding cross-functional, cross-regional Hub teams with lifecycle ownership of vehicle programmes, built to hold and coordinate the ecosystem rather than control it. A relational response focused on delivering Structural and Emotional Containment while mobilising collective Agency (see SEA Containment, Western 2026), aiming to shift the hero-crisis culture toward one that was collaborative, relational, and shared challenges openly.
The paper closes by turning a critical eye on our own theories and practices of systems psychodynamics asking what may be lacking when working in today's precarious, interdependent age.