Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Farewell to the Master: Communicating the Mysteries of Psychoanalysis from 1917 to 2027

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP27B
Presenter: Nick Waggett
Moderator: to be announced

Profile_photo.jpg

Nick Waggett

 

Nick Waggett?is course lead for the Professional Doctorate in Consulting and Leading in Organizations at Tavistock Education and Training. He has taught on several academic programmes and provides consultancy to organizations and leaders in the public sector. His research and writing focusses on the impact of?new technologies?on organizational processes. Nick was previously Chief Executive of the Association of Child Psychotherapists and has a background in workforce development.

My aim in this presentation is to open a debate about our use of historically and socially contingent language, how this might impact our ability to connect with diverse organizational clients, and whether we can find new methods of surfacing and describing unconscious processes that have meaning and resonance for them and their context.

My starting point is to situate Freud’s analogy “the ego is not the master in its own house” in the social, political and cultural context of Vienna in 1917. The phrase comes from Freud’s (1917) paper “Difficulties in the path of psycho-analysis” and is a metaphor used to convey his view of the far-reaching and persistent influence of the unconscious on a person’s psychological life and their identity. Because such psychoanalytic phenomena are difficult to describe directly: “Metaphor is a necessary part of Freud's formulation and exposition of his scientific theories” (Edelson, 1983, p.1). To do this he drew on imagery and references, such as from the Greek and Latin classics, that had meaning to him and his readers. However, if the meaning of a metaphor such as “the ego is not the master in its own house” has changed in the subsequent 110 years it will carry a different signification to that understood by Freud and his followers. The meaning of metaphor is contingent on the position of the reader.

In 1917, Freud was living in relative comfort at Berggasse 19 with his wife, children and household staff, but the city of Vienna was the ‘home front’ of the First World War which affected everybody's life: “...people were finally starving. Demonstrations and hunger protests were the harbingers of the eventual collapse of the monarchy” (Wien Museum, 2014). Rising antisemitism would impact Freud and his family directly. Therefore, the analogy of being, or not being, master in one’s own house would have had a particular resonance and meaning to him and his followers.

In today’s context the analogy is likely to have very different meanings, not least in light of the problematization of the term ‘master’ via feminism and post-colonialism due to its connection to male dominance and the slave trade. This change in the meaning of the signifier highlights the need to treat such metaphors as being only one possible way to capture and communicate the signified phenomena, such as the ineffable functioning of the unconscious. Other analogies and metaphors may greater resonance and relevance for a contemporary psychoanalytic understanding of organizations.

By freeing our language, we can work better with organizational clients from diverse socio-economic backgrounds to find ways of understanding the dynamic unconscious that have meaning and resonance to them and their context. This can contribute to processes of decolonialising psychoanalytic work with organizations. I will suggest the use of creative methodologies including art as ways to surface and give meaning to unconscious dynamics and to find new analogies that connect with a wider audience.