Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Is the researcher Master in their own house?

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP275
Presenter: Benjamin Pascal and Thibault De Swarte
Moderator: to be announced

photo-profil.jpg

Benjamin Pascal

Thibault De Swarte

Benjamin Pascal
Doctoral student in change management, my academic and professional background is closely linked to psychoanalysis and change management. Through a psychosociological lens, I study the relationship between organizational transformations and subjectivity, with a particular focus on state-owned companies and public services.

Echoing the theme of the ISPSO conference and Freud’s maxim that “the ego is not master in its own house,” this paper questions the researcher’s position of mastery in the knowledge production process. One question guides our inquiry: why does the contemporary reflexive turn in organization studies still leave so little room for the researcher’s subjectivity?

Restudies—approaches that return to previously studied empirical materials, cases, or interpretations in order to reconsider them in light of new theories, new data, or historical and social transformations—provide a particularly revealing example of this phenomenon. Indeed, the reflexivity that characterizes restudies focuses primarily on the epistemic conditions that make new interpretations possible. Far less attention is paid to how biographical, affective, and unconscious transformations of the researcher may reshape their own perspective.

How, then, can we understand this relative effacement of subjectivity within methodologies that nevertheless claim to be reflexive? Drawing on the Lacanian concept of the “discourse of science,” we hypothesize that this absence is not simply a methodological oversight, but reflects an ideal of knowledge in which knowing tends to become detached from the subjective position of the person who produces it. This ideal of mastery may persist even within certain reflexive qualitative approaches when researchers interrogate the social, historical, or theoretical conditions of their knowledge without examining how their own history and desire shape what they are able—or unable—to see in the field.

To work through this illusion of mastery and enrich reflexive qualitative methods in management through a psychoanalytic perspective, we propose a clinical approach attentive to the subjective temporality of research. To this end, we mobilize the psychoanalytic notion of deferred action (Nachträglichkeit), as reworked by Lacan. As both a conceptual and methodological resource. Nachträglichkeit enables us to conceptualize how an element encountered during fieldwork may become intelligible only at a later point, when subsequent experiences and transformations in the researcher’s subjective position retrospectively confer new meaning upon it.

We put this proposition to the test through the clinical reanalysis of organizational fieldwork conducted nearly twenty years earlier. This reanalysis shows how an element observed during the initial inquiry, but left unresolved because it could not be elaborated at the time, later acquires new significance. This shift does not result solely from the acquisition of new knowledge or theoretical frameworks; it also becomes possible because the subjective position from which the researcher encounters their own empirical material has changed. The case thus demonstrates concretely how Nachträglichkeit can operate as a methodological device for reinterpreting qualitative material.

The researcher, therefore, is not master in their own house either. They do not fully control either the meaning their empirical material may come to acquire or the temporality through which that meaning may emerge. The analysis thus invites us to consider the incompleteness of the initial inquiry not merely as a methodological limitation to be overcome, but as a possible condition for the production of new knowledge.