Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Systemic betrayal: Emotional defences and containment in rape investigations

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP273
Presenter: Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen and Brigitte Dragsted
Moderator: to be announced

Profilbillede_IOA_Elisabeth_Naima_Mikkelsen.jpg
Profilbillede_Brigitte_Dragsted.jpg

Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen

Brigitte Dragsted

Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen is associate professor of organizational psychology at the Department of Organization, Copenhagen Business School. Her research examines the role of emotions in organizations, using qualitative methods such as ethnography and in-depth interviews to generate nuanced, context-sensitive analyses. Drawing on rich empirical studies of prisons, mental health care, and law enforcement, her work demonstrates how emotions operate as powerful forces that shape organizing dynamics.

Brigitte Dragsted is a program manager and postdoctoral researcher at Queen Mary’s Centre at the University of Copenhagen where she works with research mobilization and the contribution of academic research towards societal impact. She has a background in anthropology and PhD degree from the Department of Politics and Society at Aalborg University. Her research explores how policing often entails relationships, intimacies and the destabilization of boundaries between the public and the private. She work with ethnographic methods and enjoy interdisciplinary collaboration.

Description and aims. Rape investigations are characterised by profound ambiguity, as they often involve private encounters, limited physical evidence, and contested accounts of consent, making it difficult for police officers to establish what occurred (Murphy-Oikonen et al., 2024). We suggest that rape investigations confront officers with the limits of their own mastery: the desire for certainty and control repeatedly meets the irreducible incompleteness of the evidence before them. Prior research shows that ‘rape myths’, that is false and stereotyped beliefs about rape, victims, and perpetrators (Burt, 1980), can function as cognitive schemas that reduce this ambiguity (Garza & Franklin, 2021; Sleath & Bull, 2017). In this workshop, we explore their less examined emotional function: how such beliefs may help officers manage anxiety stirred up by investigative uncertainty and the impossibility of the investigative task.

We present a qualitative case study comprising 54 longitudinal interviews with 22 newcomers to the Danish police force as they progressed into sworn service and interviews with 22 experienced detectives. Drawing on systems psychodynamic (Jaques, 1955; Menzies, 1960; Petriglieri & Petriglieri, 2020), we examine how officers’ efforts to contain investigative ambiguity generate unconscious social defences. Central to this inquiry is how these defences giving rise to irrational actions become customary and collective ways of working because they help officers cope with otherwise overwhelming emotions (Vince, 2019).

Across both groups, we identify an unacknowledged motivation for perpetuating the myth that women frequently fabricate rape allegations: a fantasy of certainty defending against the incompleteness of the investigative task.

Officers entered policing with an idealised purpose of supporting victims but soon met the limits imposed by scarce “objective” evidence, stirring up painful emotions, including an unconscious sense of betraying those they had pledged to protect. To cope, they split off and projected feelings of betrayal onto victims, who came to be seen as betrayers, shifting their identification from victim to suspect. These dynamics help explain the persistence of rape myths.

Using this case, the workshop invites participants to examine how social defences transform organizational anxieties into seemingly rational beliefs and practices.

Target group. The workshop is intended for researchers, consultants, and organizational practitioners interested in systems psychodynamics, social defences, anxiety and containment in emotionally demanding settings.

Learning outcomes. Participants will learn to:

1) Recognize how anxiety arising from ambiguity and emotionally demanding tasks can generate social defences.

2) Identify psychodynamic defence mechanisms, including splitting and projective identification, and how they become embedded in collective beliefs and practices.

3) Apply a systems psychodynamic lens to empirical material and develop interpretations of the unconscious emotional dynamics underlying organizational practices.

Working methods.
We propose a 30-minute presentation introducing the empirical case and key systems psychodynamic concepts. This will be followed by 15 minutes of small-group discussion, in which participants will use these concepts to discuss the case. A 30-minute facilitated large-group discussion will further explore how systems psychodynamic enriches our understanding of how unconscious defences can become embedded in apparently rational organizational practices.