Help us sharing our research, consultation and experiences

Donate Now

The walls within: working with defenses against otherness

Online Conference 5-11 July 2021

ISPSO ANNUAL MEETING 2027

February 2–7, 2027
Vienna, Austria

Lifting the strategy ceiling: no master alone in its own house

Parallel Papers Session
Date & Time: to be announced
Paper code: PP272
Presenters: Philip Boxer & Moritz Senarclens de Grancy
Moderator: to be announced

PJB_IMG_2742.jpg
msg4.jpg

Philip Boxer

Moritz Senarclens de Grancy

Philip Boxer — BSc (Engineering), MSc (Business Administration), PhD (Information Science) — is a strategy consultant who develops his clients' capacity to lead in highly networked, digitalized environments. His work helps client systems build relational agility, scale collaborative learning across their networks, and put platform architectures to work in support of both. He is a member of the IEEE and the International Society for the Psychoanalytic Study of Organizations, and trained with the Centre for Freudian Analysis and Research, the Lacanian school in London. His research and writing make the case for a ‘third epoch’ in how we understand and work through organizations' maladaptive responses to the asymmetric demands of turbulent environments, one that can hold the dynamics of relating to multi-sided demands that earlier epochs do not. Behind all of this is one question: why, when citizens are expected to work for their economies, are economies not expected to work for their citizens?

In 1917, in Vienna, Freud told his audience that the ego is not master in its own house. This paper carries that disturbance into organizations. It asks why so many of them run up against a limit, a level of ambition, of responsiveness, of openness to what those they serve actually want, beyond which they will not go, even when a sound strategy, a workable reorganization and sustainable targets all exist. This limit is the strategy ceiling: the ceiling that separates the part of an organization that decides what it is for and how it is to be run from the part that does the work. Those at the edges of an organization know the symptom — the opportunity is there but it never gets pursued.

We argue that lifting the ceiling is at root an ethical act, and that what has to change is not strategy or structure but the libidinal economy in the ways people work, based on what matters to them personally. Not to lift a ceiling is both a fantasy of omnipotence and a fear of incompleteness. Following Freud, individuals are doubly subjected: while they must keep themselves going in the practical sense, what matters for each one is his or her relation to a constitutive lack, a relation to an incompleteness felt as anxiety. An organization and its leadership can offer the omnipotent consolation of a guarantor — ownership of a market, a system, a technology (now, conspicuously, artificial intelligence) — that enables those identified with its current operations to minimize uncertainty, limit dependencies and preserve outsiders’ interests as secondary to their own. Resistance to changes by those above the ceiling are, at root, defenses against the anxiety of having to deal with an incompleteness. Drawing on the different ways Lacan's four discourses bear the relation to lack and on the Bionic forms of transferential relation they support, we show how those defenses form the libidinal economy of an organization, the conservation of which resists the very openness to change that its leadership may espouse and its customers ask for.

This libidinal economy above the strategy ceiling of an organization, its organization-of-the-organization that is the corollary in a person of the unconscious ego, is where the phantasy of being master in one's own house lives. We show why the lifting of a ceiling cannot be decreed from above but can only be brought about from the edges of an organization. We trace this dynamic across three scopes of individual, organization and ecosystem, showing that, at each scope, the defenses against the anxiety of bearing incompleteness are an ethical failure to address the impossibilities it faces, challenges to innovate, with consequences for how it creates and captures value.

For leaders, this is both uncomfortable and freeing: leverage comes from wherever the impossibility is, by developing the libidinal economy through which people can bear a more open relation to both their own lack and to that of those others they serve.

Keywords: omnipotence; incompleteness; strategy ceiling; libidinal economy of discourses; double subjection; the four discourses; anxiety; leadership; ethics; systems-psychodynamics

Summary
A paper carrying Freud's "the ego is not master in its own house" into organizations. Many hit a strategy ceiling — the divide between those who decide an organization's purpose and governance and those who do the work — beyond which they won't go, even with sound strategy and structure. Lifting it is fundamentally an ethical act: what must change is not strategy but the libidinal economy of how people work, rooted in what matters to them personally. Individuals are doubly subjected — each one's relation to a constitutive lack, an incompleteness felt as anxiety. Organizations offer omnipotent consolation (ownership of a market, technology, now AI) that lets insiders minimize uncertainty and treat outsiders as secondary. Resistance above the ceiling is a defense against that anxiety. Drawing on Lacan's four discourses and Bionic transferential relations, the authors show these defenses conserve a libidinal economy resisting the openness leaders espouse. Ceilings lift only from the edges — leverage lies wherever the impossibility is.

Learning outcomes
The aim is to respond to the question: why does a sound strategy so often fail to move an organisation, and what would it take — ethically, not just technically — to lift the limit it meets?

The learning:

(i) Understand how the ‘strategy ceiling’ is set by an economy of how people relate to what matters to them, and can be lifted only by bearing incompleteness from its edges; the omnipotent wish for a guarantor (increasingly, an AI one) is precisely the defence that keeps it in place.

(ii) Recognise that incompleteness is not to be eliminated but borne and apply how the anxiety of a ceiling can be held well enough to be worked rather than defended.

(iii) Distinguish the paper’s usable account of the lever of change from the omnipotent promise that any account could make the raising of a ceiling easy.